« February 2008 | Main | April 2008 »

March 2008

March 27, 2008

Lost Greensboro: The Benbow House Hotel

Benbow_hotel_greensboro_historical_In the economic devastation that followed the Civil War, Greensborough’s reputation as a city of comfortable hotel accommodations was badly bruised. Earlier fine hotels such as the Southern Hotel on West Street and the Planter Hotel on East Street were becoming worn and did not meet the improved standards set by wealthy northern industrial and port cities.

In recognizing the diminished state of Gate City hostelries, Dr. D. W. C. Benbow erected Benbow House one block south of Court House Square on South Street (South Elm Street). The hotel was built at a cost of $40,000, a lofty sum during the Reconstruction Era. The Benbow opened with great fanfare in late May 1871, featuring a dedication speech by former New York Governor David Hill, and former North Carolina Governor Zebulon Vance being the first to register as a guest.

The building was an architectural masterpiece of French-inspired Second Empire style, featuring tall windows popularized in Paris and a diamond-patterned slate mansard roof enclosing the uppermost floor. Classical brick quoins at the corners of the building, balustrades and balconies centered above the front door, a wide modillion cornice, and a chorus line of dormer windows completed the continental European design.

Benbow_hotel_from_north_pgi_filesWhen the hotel opened, an early guest from New York was disheartened to learn that no rooms had private baths. No worries! Upon discovering this inconvenience, he visited Odell Hardware on South Street and purchased a tin bathtub there for $2.50. He returned to his hotel room with his newly purchased tub with the honor of the occupying Greensboro’s first hotel room with a private bath!

Tragically, the Benbow House hotel burned (with no loss of life) at noon on June 17, 1899. By nightfall, only the tall brick walls remained of Greensboro’s prominent hotel. The ruin was purchased by B. H. Merrimon, his wife Nellie S. Merrimon and E. P. Wharton and rebuilt at a cost of $80,000. The facility was rechristened the Hotel Guilford. The new building was even more grand than the original, complete with Wilton carpets, marble floors, and – and private baths! The Hotel Guilford was destroyed around 1930 and replaced with a building occupied by F. W. Woolworths…today under development of the International Civil Rights Museum on South Elm Street.

March 20, 2008

The Secrets of Kirkwood

Long before Kirkwood became a neighborhood of tidy post-War housing, the area featured scattered semi-rural farms and estates with notable homes and varied recreation areas.

Kirkwood_1950_3Development of neighborhoods north of Cornwallis Drive began during the roaring 20s, and fed off the success of Irving Park to the south. One by one, small family farms were developed as subdivisions, including the Kirkpatrick farm in 1928. The Kirkpatrick farm became Kirkwood, featuring patriotic names such as Liberty, Independence, and Colonial given to gridded streets with deep lots. A similar cluster of gridded streets was platted to the southwest - composed of streets with bucolic names such as Lawndale, Fernwood, Dellwood, and Fairfield (image, upper right).

Both neighborhoods had little chance for development before the stock market crash of 1929. For over a decade, streets remained largely undeveloped. Interspersed among the unbuilt lots were notable houses constructed just before the Great Depression began. Among these houses was the home of Lucille and Joseph Holt, located at 2000 Dellwood Drive.

Holt_houseThe Holt House (image, right) was built in 1927-28, by Alabama native Joseph Holt and his first wife Lucille. Holt is remembered for his leadership in Home Federal Bank; Lucille is remembered for her petite form and flaming red hair. Both Holts were well connected to Greensboro’s social scene in the late 1920s and 1930s, hosting elaborate parties in a log cabin on the grounds of their home that were followed by dancing into the night.

Gorgas_houseAs Alabama natives, the Holts asked Greensboro architect Harry Simmonds to design a residence evocative of the Gorgas House on the University of Alabama campus in Tuscaloosa (image, right). The original Gorgas House was built in 1828 as a dining hall for students. In the 1840s it was converted into a faculty residence, and after the Civil War it became the home of Josiah Gorgas, a Confederate general and seventh president of the University. The house was designed by architect William Nichols, who also won commissions in the Raleigh area. Greensboro's Holt House replicated the delicate descending stairs, portico, and symmetrical facade of the original Gorgas House.

Cast_ironWith its period style, the two-story Holt House is illustrative of growing interest in historic preservation and early American architecture in the 1920s. As the Holt House was being erected, conservation efforts were just beginning to gain momentum in Williamsburg, VA and Charleston, SC. In addition to the recreated Gorgas House design, the Holts acquired architectural elements from throughout the Old South to compliment their project. Wrought iron elements found on the front and rear verandas were purchased from historic homes being destroyed in Baltimore, MD. Doors used in the house were found in Richmond, VA. Historic sites in Alabama supplied the salvaged fountain in the yard and fireplace mantles.

The grounds of the Holt’s home were equally sumptuous, incorporating an entire block of the new subdivision. The Holts preserved the mature oaks and poplars on the property, and beneath the trees they planted extensive azalea gardens. A stream was impounded to create a pond and swimming hole. To the rear of the property, a rustic-style log house was erected for lavish dinner parties and late-night dances.

Happy times ended with the passing of Lucille Holt around 1950. Holt remarried, this time to Emmaline (married nine times, he was number seven!). Joseph Holt passed away in the late 1960s, and Emmaline moved to Florida.

In 1966, the home and grounds were purchased by Laura Dean and Lawton Gresham, who selected Clyde Elrod to orchestrate renovations of the house. As a seasoned building contractor, Elrod knew the significance of the site, and guided the Greshams in preserving the most important attributes of the property. Today, the house looks much as it did when they purchased the property over forty years ago.

Stedman_cottageWith their growing appreciation for historic preservation, the Greshams soon embarked upon a new project for the grounds of the historic Holt Home. Visiting downtown Greensboro in 1976, they became aware of the destruction of the old Major Stedman House on McGee Street for today’s Weaver Center. The grounds of the Stedman House contained a small cottage that dated to 1870. The cottage was said to have been built for Major Stedman’s aged manservant, who was too respected to be turned out upon being awarded his freedom after the Civil War. The cottage had been used as a tea and lunch room in the 1960s by preservationist Helen Miller. The Greshams acquired the Stedman Cottage and saved it from the bulldozers by relocating the Victorian structure to their Dellwood property. There, it was preserved as a guest cottage.

The Holt House and Stedman Cottage remain well-preserved landmarks in today’s Kirkwood neighborhood. Both remain benchmarks in Greensboro’s preservation movement and represent local examples of national trends in conservation. The property is an important reminder that all neighborhoods contain history that is more than skin deep. Our challenge as a city is to understand the significance of these historic sites before they are lost to bulldozers and redevelopment. Kirkwood, it seems, is home to one of Greensboro’s most treasured places.

March 18, 2008

More Clues Revealed in Albright House History

For those driving on Friendly Avenue in west Greensboro, it is clear that work is underway on one of Greensboro’s most highly anticipated restoration projects.

Img_3486Recent insights on the history of the Albright House have been confirmed by the removal of aluminum siding and interior plaster – part of the scope of work currently being completed. Evidence continued to suggest the home was constructed around 1850, and research work currently underway through a UNCG historic preservation class will likely fill in more gaps in the historical narrative.

With removal of the aluminum siding, the decorative rafter tails – previously only glimpsed through a gap – are now open to sunshine (image, upper right). The rafter tails were a direct influence of Greensboro’s own Blandwood Mansion, whose Italianate details directed a national movement of architecture style. Interestingly, the rafters are not structural. Instead, they are applied beneath the structural rafters solely as a decorative feature.

Img_3487Inside the house, the wooden sheathing used for ceiling boards in the east parlor are now exposed in the entry hall and beneath the stairs (image, center right). These wide boards are hand planed and affixed to wall studs and ceiling joists using c. 1850s period cut nails. They likely hold information on some original paint colors used in the house before the Civil War.

Structural members such as studs and joists all feature sash saw marks. Sash saws were most often water powered here in the Carolina Piedmont, and their use was quickly supplanted by steam-powered circular saws with the arrival of the Great Fayetteville and Western Plank Road through High Point in 1852. Sash saw marks are a rare treat among preservationists here in Guilford County!

Amid the many features that merely confirm previous findings, one important new find has been identified in relation to the original façade of the house. A notch cut into the front-facing wall studs has revealed the location of the ledger-strip on which the front porch roof rested. The ledger extended across the middle of Img_3500
the front façade, terminating just inside the existing windows (image, lower right). This clue supports the theory that this house once looked very similar to the Walker-Scarborough House on McGee Street in College Hill. The grand, two-story Tuscan portico currently gracing the house was possibly added in the twentieth century in a lavish “updates” of the home.

The discovery of a previously unidentified nineteenth century home in Greensboro is an unusual gift to the city for its 200th birthday! The Junior League is not taking their newfound treasure lightly as they embark on a thorough restoration of the landmark for their new headquarters. With its historic materials and features recorded, more information will likely be uncovered by historical research. Keep up with new information on the (re)discovery of the Albright House right here!

March 12, 2008

It’s All About Greensboro: Evolution of a City

Ever wondered about Greensboro’s earliest neighborhoods? Can you identify Greensboro’s primary architectural styles?

Img_0611Gayle Fripp, Greensboro historian and author, and I will join forces to help present an exploration of Greensboro’s nineteenth-century neighborhoods this Sunday, March 16 at 2:30 p.m. in Preyer Hall at the Greensboro Historical Museum. The evolution of Greensboro’s neighborhoods is a defining element in the character and personality of the Gate City. Greensboro draws its strength from being a city of neighborhoods, each with distinctive elements that add character to our city.

Gayle, whom the County Commissioners honored with the title County Historian in the 1970s, is the former Curator of Education at the Greensboro Historical Museum. She has authored several books on Greensboro history, including her landmark effort “Greensboro” A Chosen Center” published in 2001. She will lead an insightful overview of the development of the city, touching on turning-points of antebellum life, industrialization, and growth through the early twentieth century.

Img_3423I will follow Gayle’s historical review with a primer on Greensboro’s architectural history. I will cover styles of early Greensboro, illustrated by landmark properties such as the 1820 Paisley House and the 1847 Bumpass –Troy House, through the Period Revival styles exemplified by the 1929 Tudor-style Sebastian House (upper-right) and 1927 Spanish Colonial Barton House (lower-right). I hope to establish a new way for residents to view their hometown neighborhoods, with an eye towards identifying architectural styles and the context.

Gayle and I will be joined by neighborhood representatives who will share their thoughts about the unique character of their own area of town. Representatives from all four nineteenth-century neighborhoods will be present to discuss the features that make their locale special.

Tickets: FREE Admission and FREE Parking
Info: (336)-373-2971

Greensboro Historical Museum
130 Summit Ave. Greensboro, NC 27401

UPDATE 3/14/08: This event is fully booked! Maybe we can offer it again sometime soon!

March 05, 2008

Exclusive Biltmore Tour Scheduled for May 6th

Knoxvillebiltmore_044Preservation Greensboro Incorporated is pleased to announce its Tours of Historic Treasures schedule for the spring of 2008. The program is designed to offer a full spectrum of “behind the scenes” tours of landmark sites and historic districts in and around Greensboro and North Carolina. These tours will help answer those aching questions such as ‘I wonder what the history of this neighborhood is?’ or ‘I wonder what the inside of that house is like?' You will open doors to parts of Biltmore house that perhaps you never dreamed of exploring.

The first destination for 2008 is the famed Biltmore House in Asheville, scheduled for Wednesday, May 6. In addition to the house audio tour, a Museum Services staff member will personally guide Preservation Greensboro’s guests in a behind-the-scenes tour of the Louis XV Suite, presently under restoration. The suite is on the second floor of the southwest tower, with spectacular mountain vistas. Intact Louis XV-style furnishings were favorites of the family, while the hand-painted ceramic tile Tyrolean mantel incorporates souvenirs collected by George Vanderbilt. As a bonus, horticultural staff will provide special commentary on Biltmore’s famed gardens decked out in beautiful spring splendor. A three-course meal is provided at Deer Park Restaurant, located on Biltmore property. Comfortable motor coach transportation is included. Cost of the day long excursion is $155, and reservations may be made by calling Judith Kastner, Executive Assistant of Preservation Greensboro at (336) 272-5003. Checks should be made out to PGI, P. O. Box 13136, Greensboro, NC 27415. Reservations must be made by April 1, 2008.

The focus of Preservation Greensboro is in saving our community’s historic and architectural treasures, this tour comes from our unique perspective, focusing on architecture, design, and history of place. Our guests can gain insights on the past by looking at cues in the architecture of a landmark such as Biltmore. Preservation Greensboro has been working to save Greensboro landmarks for over 40 years, and we are positioned to give interesting tours that reveal the depth and history of Greensboro and the surrounding communities. We think you will have a great time.

Tuesday, May 6, 2008 Schedule

8:30 a.m. Departure from Greensboro

11:30 a.m. Arrive at Group Sales Office/Entrance to Biltmore Estate to pick up admission tickets

11:45 a.m. - 1:00 pm Lunch at Deerpark Restaurant

1:00 pm Travel to Biltmore House

1:30 - 3:00 pm Audio tour of Biltmore House

3:00 -3:30 pm Break

3:30 p.m. Meet your behind the scenes guide at Front Door of Biltmore House (if group is larger than 20, we will have to divide the group into sub groups)

3:30 - 4:15 pm Guided tour of Louis XV Suite in process of restoration

4:15 - 4:30 pm Break

4:30 -5:45 pm Guided Garden Walk; Your tour begins at the famous Hunt Fountain, named for architect Richard Morris Hunt, and ends in the Walled Garden.

5:45 pm Return departure for Greensboro.

Trip Package of $155.00 includes:

Elegant seasonal three-course lunch at the Deerpark Restaurant
An Audio Tour of the House
A special museum services tour of the Louis XV Suite presently under restoration.
A guided tour of the beautiful Biltmore Gardens in full spring bloom
A comfortable state-of-the-art motor coach with restroom facilities

UPDATE 4/4/08: We are no longer taking reservations for this tour. Thank you for your interest!

March 03, 2008

Green Strategies for Historic Buildings

Can we give new meaning to the name Greensboro?

Skyline_2
In April, Preservation Greensboro will host the National Preservation Institute's workshop on combining efforts of green design with historic preservation. The session, entitled "Green Strategies for Historic Buildings" will be led by Boston architect Jean Carroon, AIA, LEED, principal of preservation at Goody Clancy.

The April 10, day-long workshop will qualify for 6 learning units in the American Institute of Architects Continuing Education System. This is the first such workshop of its kind in North Carolina.

The seminar will review practical applications of using green building strategies for historic structures. The environmental goal of "reduce, reuse, recycle" can enhance the cost competitiveness of preservation projects. Participants will review the LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) standards used to assess building performance. They will also focus on preservation challenges relating to energy efficiency, windows, lighting, indoor air quality, HVAC, and local and national codes and regulations.

Tuition is charged for the seminar that will take place in the Blandwood Carriage House at 447 West Washington Drive. For additional information including the seminar description, agenda, and registration material, please visit the NPI Website or contact the National Preservation Institute at Telephone: 703.765.0100 or email.

Greensboro is gaining ground in efforts to grow more environmentally responsible. Historic preservation is an important part of building recycling, and this event is sure to reveal valuable information in putting the GREEN in Greensboro.